Of all of the strategies I’ve used with the kids I’ve taught, close reading has been the most effective at helping my students with reading comprehension. Why is that? I believe it teaches children to not just read the words and get surface level understandings. Rather, it requires engagement and high level thinking. In this post, I will share the close reading process. I hope that these tips might provide support as many approach end of year assessments.
What is Close Reading?
Close reading is not moving your paper closer to your eyes (one of the kids suggested this today). It is not rereading alone. Close reading is active engagement with the text demonstrated by annotations that highlight important points. For successful use of close reading, the teacher should model with think aloud to model how to analyze the importance of information AS we read. Thinking aloud is very important and should be used with read alouds, articles, and even with anchor charts we use. This is especially imporant as we scaffold the instruction for your struggling readers (or when you first share it with your students for the first time). Gradually, you want them to take over the responsibility and independently do it.
If you are looking for a great teacher resource book about Close Reading, Chris Lehman’s book, Falling in Love with Close Reading offers a thorough explanation of how and why it works. I heard Chris speak two years ago. During his presentation, he used song lyrics for the text for modeling with us, and that is an important point. Any text can be used for this strategy, and in fact, using a variety of texts is necessary for our kids. Here are a few tips I learned from his book…
Read through different lenses in order to select specific information.
According to Chris, Close Reading is “making careful observations” of something and then “developing interpretations from those observations”. In other words, we stop to look carefully at choices an author (or painter or musician or director or architect) has made, and then develop ideas from what we have noticed (stop and jot). This means students read with different lenses to match the purpose we give them and observe text evidence to fit that designated purpose.
Look for connections with the text and analyze the author’s craft.
We want our readers to be strategic in their reading and thinking. We want them to observe the author’s use of language to convey meaning and apply that learning in their own work. I tell my students all the time that reading and writing go hand-in-hand. When I share a read aloud with my kids to introduce a new writing assignment or to model a reading skill, I’m not simply reading the book. We are ANALYZING the author’s craft to apply it to our own writing ideas or using that text to practice the skill. The best way to become a strong reader or writer is to interact with strong writing that is filled with vivid vocabulary, includes varied sentence length and type, that’s well organized, and that shares a strong message or idea. As we break down the text, we are thinking, and test taking is all about thinking strategies.
Read sections of text to see how small ideas connect to the bigger picture.
As students work with the close reading strategy, their level of understanding improves. With the first reading, my students aren’t as fluent. They get the gist of the reading, and observe basic information with a pencil in hand to mark it. They scratch the surface. With the second and third visits to the text, fluency improves. We hone in on specific skills, record annotations in the margins that support our thinking and that match the assigned purpose. We share our learning and opinions with one another. It is through group discussions that we quickly see the depths of understanding our students have achieved. Will your kids reread on your state assessment? Maybe a few. I think if we can slow them down by getting them to annotate, they will improve comprehension.
Choose a variety of texts including songs, poems, articles, ads, and even books.
Close reading is a strategy that can be used with all sorts of text types. We shouldn’t confine it’s practicality to just short fiction and nonfiction stories. It works well with video clips, song lyrics, poetry, television ads, and movies. Students in upper elementary through high school have a need to talk and crave controversy. Chris gives examples of how teachers can capitalize on that energy in studying point of view, argument, and text structure. Although Chris recommends close reading for grades 5-8, I believe this strategy can be adapted for use with younger students. We can use close reading with poetry as we think about the author’s choice of words. We can model with all types of texts.
Keep instruction clear with a purpose, engaging and active, so that the strategy is transferred to other texts.
With all of this in mind, there is a routine that is used with Close Reading. Chris talks at length about what Close Reading is and is not. It is not just answering questions, doing book reports, or filling out a worksheet. It is a strategic method of looking at and using text. The focus is on the interactions between reader and text, the ideas drawn, and the conclusions made. Here are the general steps I use when doing a Close Read with my students.
First Reading-Getting the Gist
- Set the purpose for the reading.
- Assign sections of the text to read and share your expectations for marking it.
- Give time to read and a stopping point for discussion. Having kids turn and talk about the section may flush out confusions they may have.
Second Reading-Thinking More Deeply
- Set a new purpose for the reading.
- Again, read and interact with the text in sections.
- Respond to the text (questions or an organizer with a skill focus)
Third Reading-Extending Ideas
- Set a new purpose for the last reading.
- With a third reading, students must be using high level thinking which requires them to analyze the ideas included in the text for the purpose.
- The information learned from the reading is used in an extended response.
Resources for Close Reading
In working with a group of fourth graders this week who hadn’t used close reading much, I decided to begin with an anchor chart that walked through the process as we worked with a weather close reading set in one of my resources. Of course, it was new to them, and because they really hadn’t been taught to interact with the text in this way, there were a fair number of groans. However, they all expressed an understanding of how this would help them in future research projects, reading of complex materials, and with testing. Close reading would not be something to do every single day, but I think it definitely helps kids rethink their thinking about their reading.
For practice, there are certainly lots of wonderful free resources to get you started. If you [CLICK HERE], you will be taken to a list of free close reading sets. You can find close reading resource sets for all grade levels now too. I hope you’ll give them a try and see the benefits as we have at my school.
For a look at what’s available in my store, you can check out these two bundles for science. There are a few others too.
Close reading strategies really helped my students with processing information from their reading. I hope these tips and strategies help your students too.